While it never shocks me, it always amazes me how TV network execs play loose and fast with the life span of a TV show. Instead of giving things a chance to grow or develop a following, a show’s life can be cut short with the quick flick of a wrist.
The latest case in point… NBC cutting off procedural crime drama Prime Suspect after 13 episodes. While yeah it’s a remake of the British series that starred Helen Mirren, this reboot featuring a utterly fantastic Maria Bello, barely got a chance to get off the ground. Critics adore it, but the ratings aren’t super high. It’s also buried on Thursday nights, up against sap fest Greys Anatomy LA, er I mean Private Practice and CBS’s The Mentalist, two shows that have built up followings with strong lead ins. What’s NBC’s lead in? The Office (post Steve Carrell) and a new show, Whitney, which is funny but not strong enough to carry viewers.To boot, it’s not your typical procedural ala Law & Order (and please, do not get me started on that being pulled), it has been building some interesting character dynamics and storylines that has me hooked. Is it because Bello’s prickly Jane Timoney is multi-dimentional, unlike, say Sunday night stalwart CSI: Miami star David Carusoe, who is just… a bad actor? Or is it too intelligent for people to follow? One may never know.
And Prime Suspect falls in a long line of cancelled before their time. Of course every fanboy has their Arrested Development and Firefly (which honestly, I never watched either… am I better off though?). My concern still lies with hopeful-midseason-replacement-now-cut-to-15-episodes Cougar Town, which while probably has the worst title on tv (admitted so by the creator!), it’s also one of the funniest ensemble casts out there. Hey, who wants to play ‘Penny Can? (Penny Caaaan!)’ ?
My personal most devastating loss of all time was Twin Peaks. Yes, ‘Who Killed Laura Palmer’ dominated my life for two years in high school. I was hypnotized, seduced, could not wait to watch what happened next. But as the second season progressed, ABC started playing games. The worst was when they would bury episodes at 2:35am. I.Kid.You. Not. Of course it was the precursor to getting shitcanned. I think Mark Frost and David Lynch started getting pissed at the mistreatment they got from the network, so they just started fucking with people’s heads toward the end. Then again… ‘Where’s Annie?” was the best show ending twist ever. And if you don’t get it, you must check this show out.
Oh network execs. You are the problem. If a show isn’t getting ratings, you start fucking around with time slots. Getting buried on Saturday night is not a solution for a fledgling drama. It’s more like a death sentence. Granted, you take risks on shows, and they don’t always pan out. Pan Am and Playboy Club, case in point. But when you have something that critics actually like, give it a chance, maybe grow a following.
And yet, it can be so random. I still have yet to figure out what the rhyme or reason was keeping According To Jim on the air for as long as it lasted. Ddid anyone watch that show? Will anyone cop to watching that show? And why is Kathy Bates getting a plum Wednesday night slot for her show Harry’s Law? Or should I call it Ally McBeal: The Senior Years? Yawn.
So to the net execs out there, as my Thanksgiving wish, I hope you reconsider cancelling a show before you give it a fair chance. Prime Suspect in particular. I know the axe hasn’t fallen hard and fast yet, but the outlook is not good. Reprieve is in the air.
And hope does spring eternal: I mean, Family Guy was cancelled twice, and yet it’s back on the air. Even Arrested Development is getting a second life, so maybe I need to check that one out. And hey, they are even rebooting Dallas. The original cast is back except Victoria Principal, and looks like she was recast with Brenda Strong, Mary Alice from Desperate Housewives. Then, continuing with the Desperate Housewives theme, and to give it some young flair (maybe a few viewers too), the hunky boys from that show are being added as the next generation.
Yeah, maybe some things should just be left alone.